Showing posts with label KSPCB. Show all posts
Showing posts with label KSPCB. Show all posts

Monday, January 8, 2024

KSPCB: Expenditure is more than three times the income

 Approval of State Pollution Control Board Action Plan

 Expenditure is more than three times the income

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

 BENGALURU: The board meeting has approved an action plan for three times the expected revenue of the State Pollution Control Board.

 In the 243rd Board meeting, an action plan of ₹1,546.44 crore was approved despite the expected revenue of only ₹600 crore in the next three years. It is alleged that this is a plan to immediately spend the remaining ₹1,050 crore in the financial year 2023, which will bankrupt the board.

 A board member, who did not want to be named, complained that 'Such a decision has been taken to spend one thousand crores as per their wish'.

 The board meeting agreed to spend money for awareness and awareness programs including development of laboratories, water quality management system, software upgradation for 2023-24, 2024-25, 2025-26.

 The board members objected to the opinion of Chairman Shanth Thimmaiah that it is not right for the member secretary to send the agenda of the meetings to the members without the approval of the Chairman and said that the agenda can be sent to the members by the member secretary. Also, the members unanimously decided to keep the video-audio recording of the board meeting aside and put aside the chairman's words.

 The meeting approved the filling of 220 posts of the board and it was decided to request the government to fill up the rest of the posts except driver and watchman posts through the Karnataka Examinations Authority.

The State Level Enforcement Committee has been reconstituted and the members nominated by the Government have also been appointed. As per the KTPP Act, it has been decided to increase the amount of expenditure on projects approved by the Chairman and Member Secretary. It has been decided to amend the rules to increase the power of the Chairman from ₹50 lakh to ₹5 crore and that of the Member Secretary from ₹25 lakh to ₹2 crore.

 BBMP's ₹53 crore extravagance!

 The State Pollution Control Board has decided to spend ₹53 crore given by the BBMP to replace the action plan of 64 activities of the 'Vayu Yojana' selected on the Central Air Pollution Control Board's 'Prana' portal.

 The money allocated to BBMP in the 15th financial plan is being spent for monitoring air pollution, road dust study, upgrading of laboratories, vehicle air pollution monitoring, survey, study and report preparation. The board members complained that this will not be of any use.

 Project cost details

  •  finance; ₹747.66
  •  Chief Environment Officer–3; ₹233.17
  •  Waste Management Cell–1; ₹208.31
  •  administration; ₹123.71
  •  building; ₹115
  •  Groundwater Quality Study; ₹29.05
  •  IT; ₹24.50
  •  Branch of Mines and Geology; ₹18.45
  •  Awareness and training; ₹15
  •  Lake development; ₹13.35
  •  17th category and e-electronic cell; ₹7.26 crore
  •  Waste Management Cell–2; ₹7.15
  •  Legal Branch; ₹3.83
  •  Action Plan Total Amount; ₹1,546.44
  •  From prospective sources of income; ₹600
  •  Amount remaining in board till April 2023; ₹1,050

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...




Saturday, January 6, 2024

Suspension of Environment Officers

 Illegal establishment, operation consent letter for plastic processing plant

 Suspension of Environment Officers

 Bengaluru: Two environmental officers of the State Pollution Control Board have been suspended for illegally granting permission to set up and operate a plastic processing unit.

 S.K., who was a senior environmental officer in the Bengaluru South Zone and Ramanagara Zone Offices of the State Pollution Control Board.  Vasudev and C.R. who is an environmental officer in Ramanagara regional office.  Manjunath was suspended and the chairman of the board, Shant A.  Thimmaiah ordered.

 Certificates have been illegally issued to the plastic waste processing unit of Enviro Recyclene at Harohalli in Ramanagara.  On October 26, 2023, the Chairman of the Central Pollution Control Board directed the Chairman of the State Pollution Control Board that action should be taken against the concerned officer.

 The Member Secretary had instructed the Chief Environment Officer-3 to give a report on this.  The report was given on November 10, 2023.

 'S.K.  Vasudev, C.R.  Manjunath is directly responsible for the illegal case.  It is obvious that his dereliction of duty has come to light, he has acted in a manner unbecoming of board employees and has shown neglect of duty.  Hence it is deemed appropriate to take disciplinary action against you.  Being suspended as there is a possibility of destruction of evidence and documents if you continue on duty.  Your central location has been changed to Bangalore.  The board chairman explained in the order issued on January 3 that a departmental inquiry will be conducted.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ ...



Friday, November 3, 2023

Another power struggle in Pollution Control Board

 The Chairman canceled the circular issued by the Member Secretary

Another power struggle in Pollution Control Board

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

 Bengaluru: There has been a conflict of power between the chairman and the member secretary in the State Pollution Control Board.

 President Shant A. continues as the President as per the order of the High Court. Thimmaiah, Member Secretary P.C. Ray canceled the 242nd meeting circular issued on 27th A.D. on 30th A.D.

 More than 400 applications are pending before the board for approval. Under the leadership of the Forest Minister, Additional Chief Secretary, Principal Secretary, Member Secretary reviewed the issue. All these applications were decided to be disposed of by the board soon. The member secretary sent a circular to the members of the state level enforcement committee saying that this should be approved through a circular.

 The member secretary does not have the authority to call a meeting of the state level enforcement committee members of the board. However, the meeting was held on 13th A.M. without the consent of the President. Even after the instructions of the President, the member secretary issued a schedule for holding meetings on September 16, 5, 6, 7 and 10. "All this is illegal," President Shanth Tammaiah said in a letter written to the members of the state-level enforcement committee.

The circular issued by the member secretary on 27th A.D. to approve and dispose of pending files before the board is also against the Water Act and Water Pollution Prohibition and Control Rules. Such action was taken without the consent of the President. Thus, the circular issued to approve the matters of the 242nd board meeting has been cancelled. Shant Thimmaiah said in the letter that the date of the next meeting will be informed after obtaining the consent of the High Court.

 "Problems have been created, we will fight for this," said member secretary P.C. Ray responded.

 Letter to the Chief Secretary

 'Forest Department Principal Secretary BP Ravi has held a meeting of Zonal Environment Officers of the State Pollution Control Board. Along with the officials of the board, they inspected the companies in Kumbalagode, Kengeri, Shimoga, Chitradurga. This is illegal and he should be ordered not to interfere in the management of the board,' said the Chief Secretary Shanth Tammaiah in a letter to him.

' I have no information about writing a letter to the Chief Secretary. BP will not give any kind of response in this regard' BP Ravi responded.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...



Friday, September 1, 2023

KSPCB Chairman Shanth Thimmaiah sacked

Expiration date is March 2022; Amendment to appointment order

 State Pollution Control Board Chairman Shanth Thimmaiah sacked

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

 Bengaluru: State Pollution Control Board chairman Shanth Thimmaiah's tenure was expired in 2022, the state government has issued a notification on Thursday dismissing him.

 As per the Water Act and the rules of appointment of the chairman, Shant Thimmaiah has been relieved of his post with immediate effect as his term has expired. The Principal Secretary, Department of Forests, Biology and Environment has been ordered to hold the additional post of Chairman until a new Chairman is appointed.

 According to Section 5(6) of the Water Act, the tenure of the Chairman of the Board is three years. As amended in the appointment order (FEE 143 EPC 2020) issued on 15th November 2021 as per the rules for selection of the chairman, the term of the current chairman has expired on 4th March 2022.

 Amendment: According to the Water Act, the Chairman of the Pollution Control Board is being appointed, Vamanacharya appointed in 2012 and Lakshman appointed in 2015 have completed the term of three years each.

 On March 5, 2019, Jayaram was appointed as the chairman for a period of three years. He resigned on June 20, 2019. From June 21 to September 21 Dr. K. Sudhakar was the chairman. Later, Dr. Sandeep Dave from September 21 to December 21, 2019; Dr. Sudhindra Rao from December 29 to May 2, 2020; Vijayakumar Gogi from May 2 to March 1, 2021; Brijeshkumar was the President from March 1 to November 15.

Shant A. Thimmaiah assumed the post of chairman from November 15, 2021 and his term was till March 4, 2022. According to the Act and Rules, the term of office of chairman started from June 20, 2019, when Jayaram was appointed. It will end on March 4, 2022. Since Jayaram, there have been six presidents during that period. However, in the appointment order of Shanth Thimmaiah, the period is wrongly entered as upto 14th November 2024. Changing it to March 4, 2022, the amendment order was issued by the Department of Forests, Biology and Environment.

 As per this amended order, Shanth Thimmaiah has been released from the post of President on August 31 as his term has expired, the notification said.

 Allegation of bias, violation of law

Suri Payala, member secretary of the board, wrote to the government on July 3 that the Karnataka Transparency in Public Procurement Act-1999 (KTPP) had been violated to conduct awareness programs worth ₹17.85 crore in a meeting of the 'Single Source Committee' headed by the Chairman of the State Pollution Control Board, Shant Thimmaiah. In this regard, a report was published in Prajavani on July 17 under the title 'Pollution Control Board - Conflict between Government'. Former Member of Legislative Council P.R. Ramesh had written a letter to the Chief Minister demanding an investigation. Based on all this, the government formed an inquiry committee.

The state pollution control board chairman has violated the laws in ordering awareness programs. According to the Water Pollution Act 1974 and the Air Pollution Act 1981, the Chairman of the Board has no power to constitute any committee. The investigation committee of State Audit and Accounts Department Additional Director Mahadeva, appointed by the state government, had given a preliminary report that President Shanth Tammaiah had formed a single committee in violation of it.

 The report also stated that considering the proposal of five firms for giving advertisement worth ₹19.92 crore, considering four firms as a single source firm, with the intention of awarding contracts to targeted persons, bias was found with the intention of controlling competition. Prajavani published a report on this on August 17. The report of the inquiry committee is to be submitted to the government in its entirety.


ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...

Thursday, August 17, 2023

KSPCB: Violation of the Act by the Chairman

 State Pollution Control Board: Bias in ₹₹19.92 crore contract

KSPCB: Violation of the Act by the Chairman 


Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

BENGALURU: The State Pollution Control Board's CHAIRMAN has violated the laws in ordering awareness programs, according to the report of the inquiry committee appointed by the state government.

As per Water Pollution Act 1974 and Air Pollution Act 198, the CHAIRMAN of the Board has no authority to constitute any committee. It is clearly mentioned in the report that Chairman Shanth Thimmaiah has formed the single source committee in violation of acts.

State Audit and Accounts Department Additional Director Mahadeva is the investigating officer of the committee constituted by the government. It is said in the report that the decision to select a single source organization was taken with the intention of awarding contracts to the planned institutions.

 The CHAIRMAN of the board has appointed a self-proclaimed chairman of the single source organization. A committee of three experts should be constituted under the Transparency Act 1999 -4(b). The members should be experts in the same subject on the board.

 An office memorandum was issued by the CHAIRMAN himself, who constituted a single parent organization. This committee was constituted with the objective of giving approval to five organizations to give planned advertising works. Considering the proposal of five firms for advertisement worth ₹19.92 crore, four firms are considered as single source firm. As per Section 15(e) of the State Government Rules, 1976, the CHAIRMAN can approve only tenders worth ₹25 thousand in each case, the report said.

 A short term tender of 35 days could have been invited. Without considering it, it was found to be biased with the intention of awarding contracts to the scheme persons, with the intention of controlling competition.

The single source agency was chosen with the intention of awarding contracts to the proposed organizations without the prospect of reaching more people with environmental awareness programs, the report said.

 In addition to this, in a letter written by Mahadeva to the Member Secretary of the Pollution Control Board on August 16, a proposal for readjustment in the budget of ₹24.60 crore has also been submitted to the board meeting. It has been suggested to provide the copies of the power transfer order received from the government for readjustment to these account headings.

 Background of the case

 A meeting of the 'Single Source Committee' chaired by Board CHAIRMAN Shant Thimmaiah agreed to award the contract to specific agencies in violation of the Karnataka Transparency in Public Procurement Act-1999 (KTPP) to carry out awareness programs worth ₹17.85 crore. Suri Payala, who was the member secretary of the board, had written a letter to the government saying that all this is a violation of the KTPP Act and action should be taken in this regard. The Principal Secretary of the Department of Environment and Biodiversity had written to him on July 3 and given all the information approved in the 'Single Source Committee' meeting. Based on this, the government formed an inquiry committee.

 In this regard, a report was published in 'Prajavani' on July 17 under the title 'Conflict between Pollution Control Board - Government'.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ..

ರಾಜ್ಯ ಮಾಲಿನ್ಯ ನಿಯಂತ್ರಣ ಮಂಡಳಿ ಅಧ್ಯಕ್ಷರಿಂದ ಕಾಯ್ದೆ ಉಲ್ಲಂಘನೆ



Monday, July 17, 2023

Smells of corruption in Pollution Control Board (KSPCB)

 ₹17.85 crore illegal in awareness program; A complaint to the government from the member secretary

Smells of corruption in Pollution Control Board (KSPCB)

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

Bengaluru: The State Pollution Control Board, which is supposed to eliminate many filth in the state, has messed up its yard due to personal conflicts and irregularities.

 In a meeting of the 'Single Source Committee' chaired by Board Chairman Shant Thimmaiah, ₹17.85 crore worth of awareness programs were directly given to the agencies in violation of the Karnataka Transparency in Public Procurement Act-1999 (KTPP). The board has also given approval and mandate for these awareness advertising programs for a few months before the assembly elections. Now the bill amount is pending release.

 In the meeting held on January 30, the contract worth ₹17.85 crore was approved to be awarded to specific agencies. Also approved for issue of purchase order. All this is a violation of the KTPP Act and the member secretary of the board, Suri Payala, has written a letter to the government saying that action should be taken in this regard. The Principal Secretary of the Department of Environment and Biodiversity wrote a letter to him on July 3 and gave all the information approved in the 'Single Source Committee' meeting.

After this letter case, there was conflict in the board and the chairman Shanth Thimmaiah has withdrawn the post of joint secretary in addition to IT director Suri Payala. Many cases have been mentioned in the recall order that Suri Payala has also exercised his authority in violation of the rules.

 What is awareness program?: The board meeting gave approval to four agencies to display awareness programs of State Pollution Control Board in the form of advertisements on buses, residential areas. Sai Advertisers have been approved to introduce GST as 'branding fee' on 2000 buses of KSRTC and KKRTC and 100 buses of BMTC Volvo.

 Adon Mo Agency has been given a month's advertisement at 400 bus stands in Bengaluru to display the ad on 4,692 screens approved by DAVP (Directorate of Audio and Visual Programmes).

 It was also agreed in the meeting to issue a purchase order to Benaka Automotives to display advertisements on the bus panels of North-West Karnataka Road Transport Corporation in Hubli and put up 22 hoardings in Haveri district.

 Action as Act; Money not released: Shant Thimmaiah

 There is an opportunity to carry out awareness programs directly. However, I made the Committee as Single Source Agencies as per Section 4(b) of the KTPP Act, where it was discussed, programs were given to agencies approved by the Government. After this, the matter was proposed and approved in the board meeting as well. After the awareness programs are completed, the bills are received from the agencies and the committee headed by the member secretary has been assigned to review them. No report was received from that committee. So not even a single rupee has been released to any agency. I have not violated any law and I will not," said Shant Thimmaiah, President of the State Pollution Control Board.

 Demand a thorough investigation

 The Chairman of the State Pollution Control Board and some officers have directly entrusted the responsibility of awareness advertisement programs to private companies in violation of the KTPP Act. During the previous government's period, this was the pretext of misappropriation of public money under the guise of awareness before the assembly elections. Incompetent and incompetent President and concerned officials were found to have committed corruption. Thus, the Chief Minister Siddaramaiah should be urged to form a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to investigate all the decisions and resolutions taken by the State Pollution Control Board during the term of this President, former member of the Legislative Council P.R. Ramesh said.

 Awareness program: Who is allowed?

 agency; content; duration; amount

  •  Sai advertisers, Chokkasandra, Peenya; mass awareness program by 'Bus Branding Media' about State Pollution Control Board; 2 months; ₹3,40,80,000
  •  Adan Mo Rethinking Out Door Advertising, Bangalore; branding and advertising in housing societies; 3 months; ₹7,53,41,508
  •  Sign Post India, Halasur, Bangalore; OOH (Out of Home Out Door) advertising across Bangalore; 1 month; ₹5,43,84,000

  •  Benaka Automations, Jayanagar, Bangalore; Awareness advertisement about State Pollution Control Board in buses across the state; 1 month; ₹1,47,36,000
  • Total; ₹17,85,41,508
ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...



Tuesday, February 21, 2023

BWSSB STPs not following norms

 NGT Norm: only 8 out of 31 STPs are with in parameters

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

Bengaluru: Out of the 31 STPs managed by BWSSP in the city, only 8 are treating waste water as per norms, while the remaining STPs are exceeding the norms of National Green Bench (NGT) and State Pollution Control Board, according to a report by ActionAid.

After 45 days of monitoring the statistics of STPs recorded on the BWSSB website itself, the agency has prepared a study report on them. 1042.5 million liters of waste water is treated daily in 31 STPs. Studied from Nov 1 to Dec 15, 2022. Six criteria are compared to assess the quality of water treatment.

Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD), Potential Hydrogen (pH), Total Suspended Solids (TSS), Ammonical Nitrogen and Total Nitrogen levels were studied following measurement. Raghavendra B.Pachchapur, Program Manager of ActionAid, said that except for 8 STPs, these standards are not being followed.

The TSS level should be less than 10 mg per liter as per Pollution Control Board standards. But BWSSB has set this level at 20 mg. Similarly, if the pH level is set at 6.5–9 instead of 6.5–8.5, there is no measurement of coliform, the human-animal waste that causes many diseases.

What SPTs are like?:

Only STPs at Doddabele, Cubbonpark, yelemallappa Chetty, Mylasandra, Kempambudhi, Rajacanal (New), Agar and Hulimavi are following all the norms.

Kengeri, Rajacanal (old), Hebbala, K&C Valley-30 and 218 are not providing sample data.

The data of STPs in Yalahanka TTP, Halasur, Bellandur Amani lakes is alarming and full of misinformation. Jakkuru STP is in very poor condition. Exceeds all standards.

All norms of National Green Bench (NGT), Pollution Control Board should be followed. It should be monitored by Pollution Control Board. The study suggested that the treated water discharged to the lake and other areas should be of the same standard.

'A fish is not worth living...'

BWSSB says water is discharged from its waste water treatment plants (STPs) into the lakes. The word people use is far away. At least the water in the lake is enough for the fish to survive. With such a purpose, we have studied the water flowing from STPs by collecting the data available on their website. A copy of this will also be submitted to BWSSB, Urban Development Department, State Pollution Control Board, ActionAid's Raghavendra B. Pachchapur said.

Upgradation will be done...

Many of the STPs of BWSSB are very old and cannot meet the norms laid down now. Thus, work is being done to upgrade the STPs to meet the NGT norms, informed Gangadhar, STP Department, BWSSB.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ..

ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು: ಬಿಡಬ್ಲ್ಯೂಎಸ್‌ಎಸ್‌ಬಿ ಮಾನದಂಡ ಅನುಸರಿಸದ ಎಸ್‌ಟಿಪಿಗಳು



Wednesday, January 25, 2023

Karnataka: River water is not fit for drinking



State Pollution Control Board Report

17 River water is not fit for drinking

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

25 January 2023

Bengaluru: The water of any river in the state including Krishna, Kaveri, Tungabhadra, Kabini, Shinsha, Malaprabha, Ghataprabha, Bhima, Hemavati, Netravati, Yagachi, Karanja is not suitable for drinking without treatment.

The State Pollution Control Board on Tuesday published the report on the water quality of rivers and lakes from April to November 2022 under the National Water Quality Scheme. According to this, the water quality of rivers and lakes of the state is declining.

The Pollution Control Board has 103 inspection stations in various districts in the flow of 17 rivers of the state. From there take a water sample and check it, recording the quality. As the Karanja river sample was not collected in Bidar, its report is not given. Water levels are identified in five categories.

Netravati river water flowing in Dharamsthala was bathable in October. However, in the November report, the pollution has increased and has slipped from B category to C category. As a result, this water is not even suitable for bathing outdoors. Kumaradhara river before joining Netravati in Uppinangadi city of Mangalore, Kagina river in Kalaburagi, water of Suvarnavati reservoir at Attigullipura of Chamarajanagar, water of Bhadra river near Bhadravati MPM has increased pollution and has fallen from B category to C category.

Tungabhadra water level in Davangere has lost its drinking quality and has fallen from 'C' category to 'D' category. The confluence of Sangam and Kanakapura in Ramanagara, Cauvery in Sangam, Sedam in Kalaburagi, Kagina in Shahabad bridge and Bennitora reservoir, Bhima in Gangapur, Kattemalalavadi in Mysore and Lakshmanatheerth in Mysore, Tungabhadra in Davanagere, yedeyuru in Tumkur are potable. The Dakshina Pinakini river flowing in Sarjapur on the outskirts of Bangalore is in 'E' category, metal-rich and polluted.

The water of 17 rivers of the state is not suitable for direct drinking. Not only that, it is known from the state pollution control board report that there is no potable water source even after normal treatment.

Water Quality of Rivers (November 2022)

 103: Checkpoints

 0– Class A: Drinking water source. It requires conventional processing first.

 19- Class B: Can be used for outdoor bathing.

 67– Class C: Source of drinking water. But, first disinfection and then conventional processing should be done.

 15 – Class D: Potable for wildlife and fishable

 1– E Class: Metal, impure, treated and used for irrigation, industry

Pollution of Lakes: 

The Pollution Control Board has tested the water quality of 69 lakes in districts other than Bangalore, and there are no 'A' class lakes. Bairamangala and Ramamma Lakes in Ramanagara, Melekote in Tumkur, Bhimasandra Lake, Dalwai in Mysore, Oilhole Lake, Hassan Mathana and Howali Lakes are in 'E' category. There are 5 lakes in 'B' category, 18 in 'C' category and 32 in 'D' category.



Bengaluru Lakes Water: Wildlife Drinkable!

Pollution Control Board is testing water quality in 106 lakes of Bangalore city. Of these, only 66 lakes have water suitable for drinking and fishing by wildlife. The rest of the lakes are the site of impurities including metal and sewage.

Subramanyapura, Mallattahalli, Dorekere, Hoskerehalli, Shivapura, Karihobanahalli, Dasarahalli, Gangondanahalli, Andhrahalli, Kachohalli, Vishwaneedam, Machohalli, Dodbidarakallu, Bommanahalli, Madiwala, Hulimavu, Singasandra, Parappana Agrahara, Haralur, Maharapadarapur, Maharajadevapura under Rajarajeshwarinagar range. , Vibhutipur, Chellakere in Yalahanka range, Singapore, Narasipura, Rachenahalli, Kogilu, Halasur in the eastern part, Bairasandra lakes are the sites of metallic impurities. There are no lakes in category A, B, C. There are 66 lakes in 'D' category and 40 lakes in 'E' category. The number of lakes in category 'E' has increased in November as compared to October.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...