Showing posts with label advertisement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label advertisement. Show all posts

Thursday, August 17, 2023

KSPCB: Violation of the Act by the Chairman

 State Pollution Control Board: Bias in ₹₹19.92 crore contract

KSPCB: Violation of the Act by the Chairman 


Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

BENGALURU: The State Pollution Control Board's CHAIRMAN has violated the laws in ordering awareness programs, according to the report of the inquiry committee appointed by the state government.

As per Water Pollution Act 1974 and Air Pollution Act 198, the CHAIRMAN of the Board has no authority to constitute any committee. It is clearly mentioned in the report that Chairman Shanth Thimmaiah has formed the single source committee in violation of acts.

State Audit and Accounts Department Additional Director Mahadeva is the investigating officer of the committee constituted by the government. It is said in the report that the decision to select a single source organization was taken with the intention of awarding contracts to the planned institutions.

 The CHAIRMAN of the board has appointed a self-proclaimed chairman of the single source organization. A committee of three experts should be constituted under the Transparency Act 1999 -4(b). The members should be experts in the same subject on the board.

 An office memorandum was issued by the CHAIRMAN himself, who constituted a single parent organization. This committee was constituted with the objective of giving approval to five organizations to give planned advertising works. Considering the proposal of five firms for advertisement worth ₹19.92 crore, four firms are considered as single source firm. As per Section 15(e) of the State Government Rules, 1976, the CHAIRMAN can approve only tenders worth ₹25 thousand in each case, the report said.

 A short term tender of 35 days could have been invited. Without considering it, it was found to be biased with the intention of awarding contracts to the scheme persons, with the intention of controlling competition.

The single source agency was chosen with the intention of awarding contracts to the proposed organizations without the prospect of reaching more people with environmental awareness programs, the report said.

 In addition to this, in a letter written by Mahadeva to the Member Secretary of the Pollution Control Board on August 16, a proposal for readjustment in the budget of ₹24.60 crore has also been submitted to the board meeting. It has been suggested to provide the copies of the power transfer order received from the government for readjustment to these account headings.

 Background of the case

 A meeting of the 'Single Source Committee' chaired by Board CHAIRMAN Shant Thimmaiah agreed to award the contract to specific agencies in violation of the Karnataka Transparency in Public Procurement Act-1999 (KTPP) to carry out awareness programs worth ₹17.85 crore. Suri Payala, who was the member secretary of the board, had written a letter to the government saying that all this is a violation of the KTPP Act and action should be taken in this regard. The Principal Secretary of the Department of Environment and Biodiversity had written to him on July 3 and given all the information approved in the 'Single Source Committee' meeting. Based on this, the government formed an inquiry committee.

 In this regard, a report was published in 'Prajavani' on July 17 under the title 'Conflict between Pollution Control Board - Government'.

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ..

ರಾಜ್ಯ ಮಾಲಿನ್ಯ ನಿಯಂತ್ರಣ ಮಂಡಳಿ ಅಧ್ಯಕ್ಷರಿಂದ ಕಾಯ್ದೆ ಉಲ್ಲಂಘನೆ



Monday, July 31, 2023

Bus Shelter Advertisement: Outstanding over ₹100 crore

<script async src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js?client=ca-pub-7409631463752216"

     crossorigin="anonymous"></script>

Display at Bus Shelter, Skywalk; irrecoverable rent, fees from 2016

Bus Shelter, Skywalk Advertisement: Outstanding over ₹100 crore

Kere Manjunath ಕೆರೆ ಮಂಜುನಾಥ್

Bengaluru: Over ₹100 crore due for rent of advertisement display on bus shelter, skywalk as floor rent, service taxes, etc. Although the demand notice was issued, the authorities did not collect it. Expired ads are also not cleared.

 Fees related to advertisement of hundreds of Bus Shelters and skywalks in the city are pending since 2016. On December 5, 2022, demand notices totaling ₹ 50.27 crore have been issued to many agencies by the Assistant Commissioner of Advertising. Even though such notices continue to be issued till June, the arrears have not been paid.

 Many agencies have been given permission to construct bus shelters on Build, Operate, Transfer (BOT) basis by giving advertising rights at various locations in the city. Since 2016, many shelters have been built and advertisements are being displayed. According to the BBMP Outdoor Billboard Bye-laws dated 14th Jan, 2020, the rate has been fixed excluding GST on Public Private Partnership (PPP) type constructions.

 Advertisement fee is charged at ₹780 per square meter for bus shelters on major roads and ₹600 per square meter for bus shelters at other places. A similar charge applies to advertising displays on skywalks. Calculate like this, A demand notice has been issued to each agency for payment through DD with in 15 days. Seven months have passed since the completion of this process, but no action has been taken. Advertisements are being displayed even though the contracts of many agencies have expired.

 The details of demand notices given to dozens of companies under Right to Information Act S. Amaresh got it. According to these documents, the balance should be paid within 15 days. Otherwise legal action will be taken as per KMC Act.

 There is also a condition that the shelters should be kept clean. But, the agencies are not following that too,' complained Amaresh.

"Uncalled for tender is illegal"

 Agencies have been given to construct bus shelters and display advertisements. They have to pay ground rent and advertisement fee. However, dues have not been recovered from many agencies since 2015. The tender period of many agencies has ended since 2018 itself. But till now the dues have not been recovered from them and the advertisement has not been cleared. Due to this behavior of the officials, the BBMP has incurred hundreds of crores of financial loss. I written a letter to the BBMP Chief Commissioner and the Deputy Chief Minister, but no action has been taken, said S. Amaresh of the Right to Information Study Center has obtained details under the Right to Information Act.

Permission of senior officials is required for clearance.

 "Demand notices are being issued from December till now for the arrears of Bus shelter, skywalk advertisement, ground rent, service charge. Some have paid. The rest have been written to senior officers for action. Some tenders have expired and have to be cleared. Evacuation work should be done after giving permission from senior officials. Those who were in the past have not recovered the arrears. Now I have taken action on my arrival," said Sridhar Reddy, Assistant Commissioner, Advertising Department, BBMP. Deepak, Special Commissioner of advertisement department, was not available for contact.

 TOTAL; ₹ 57.27 crore (Amount of demand notices executed on a single day on 5th December 2022)

 Bus shelters; ₹31.67 crore

  •   Times Innovative Media; 215; ₹15.05 crore
  • Sign Post India; 139; ₹10.32 crore
  •  Digital Ad Science; 58; ₹4.84 crore
  •  OOH Advertisement Services; 16; ₹1.44 crore

 Skywalk; ₹25.69 crore

  •  Vantage Advertising; 25; ₹6.26 crore
  • Prakash Arts; 34; ₹5.67 crore
  • Collaboration – India Council;7; ₹4.76 crore
  • Pioneer Publicity Corporation; 28; ₹3.99 crore
  •  Sign Post India; 14; ₹1.90 crore
  •  Skyline Advertising; 3; ₹92.17 lakh
  •  Ad Age Outdoor Advertisement; 2; ₹₹34.08 lakh
  • Design 55 Advertisement; 4; ₹27.87 lakh
  •  Jivin Out Door Media; 2; ₹25.69 lakh
  •  Accord Display Service; 7; ₹18.44 lakh

ಕನ್ನಡದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಲು ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಕ್ಲಿಕ್ ಮಾಡಿ...